Representatives from the campaigns of Sen. Norm Coleman and Al Franken have been challenging ballots across the state.
It's your turn to play election judge. Tell us how you would rule in the case of these challenged ballots. Use this Minnesota state statute as your guide.
DAY 3 BALLOTS
Ballot #1: The Signature
The
Franken campaign challenged this ballot, arguing the voter left an
identifying mark on the ballot. (MPR has blacked-out the signature to
respect the voter's privacy.) Minnesota law states:
"If a ballot is marked by distinguishing characteristics in a manner
making it evident that the voter intended to identify the ballot, the
entire ballot is defective." (MPR Photo/Laura Yuen)
The
Franken campaign challenged this ballot in Ramsey County where the
voter appears to have written "Bachmen" — presumably a reference to
U.S. Rep. Michele Bachmann — in the write-in field. (Caroline Yang for
MPR)
The
Coleman campaign questioned this Ramsey County ballot because while the
oval for the Presidency was filled in with pen, the rest were filled in
with pencil, calling into question whether the ballot had been properly
duplicated. (Caroline Yang for MPR)
The
Franken campaign challenged this ballot in Ramsey County, arguing the
voter drew an "X" in over the oval for Norm Coleman, signifying the
voter's intent to cross-out the vote for Coleman. (Caroline Yang for
MPR)
The
Franken campaign challenged this ballot, arguing the voter left an
identifying mark (signature blurred for privacy) on the ballot.
(Caroline Yang for MPR)
The
Coleman campaign challenged this ballot in Anoka county, arguing the
voter drew an arrow pointing at Coleman's name after filling in the
bubble next to Franken's name. (MPR Photo/Curtis Gilbert)
The
Franken campaign challenged this Anoka County ballot, arguing that the
thumb print on it constitutes a distinguishing mark. If a voter signs a
ballot or writes his Social Security Number on it, that ballot is
invalid under Minnesota state law. The State Canvassing Board will need
to determine whether this thumbprint has the same effect. (MPR
Photo/Curtis Gilbert)
This
ballot was challenged in Dakota County because two ovals were filled
in. Minnesota law says a ballot is valid is election officials can
determine the voter's intent. (Image courtesy of Dakota County)
This
Beltrami County voter cast their ballot for Al Franken, but also put
"Lizard People" as a write-in candidate, not only in the U.S. Senate
race, but for several others. The county auditor/treasurer ruled that
the vote should not be counted because it's considered an overvote.
Representatives for Franken challenged that decision. (MPR Photo/Tom
Robertson)
This
Olmsted County voter placed a checkmark next to Al Franken's name and
also circled one of the guide marks for the optical scanner. The
Coleman campaign challenged the voter's intent. (MPR Photo/Sea Stachura)
The
Coleman campaign challenged this ballot, arguing the voter didn't
intend to vote for Franken, because of the small dot inside the bubble
next to Dean Barkley’s name. (MPR Photo/Curtis Gilbert)
The
Franken campaign challenged this ballot. Even though the voter filled
in the bubble next to Barkley's name, a Franken representative said
what appear to be eraser marks over Franken's bubble indicated the
voter intended to vote for Franken. (MPR Photo/Curtis Gilbert)
The
Coleman campaign kept this ballot from going into the 'Other' pile.
They argued that while the voter filled in the bubble next to Dean
Barkley, the voter had intended to vote for Coleman because of the
small dot inside Coleman's bubble. (MPR Photo/Curtis Gilbert)
The
Franken campaign challenged this ballot, arguing the voter intended to
vote for Franken. "He was underlining Al," said Franken volunteer Jeff
Lange, who made the challenge. (MPR Photo/Curtis Gilbert)
Frank O'Hara Ψ Having a Coke with You The Replacements Ψ Unsatisfied Big Star Ψ Mod Lang The Replacements Ψ Beer for Breakfast Dinosaur Jr. Ψ Feel the Pain Yap Lambchop Ψ Love TKO (Pendergast cover) Damon & Naomi Ψ Beautiful Close Double Arthur Russell Ψ Time Away Elvis Ψ Flaming Star The Flamingos Ψ Chick uhm Ba Link Wray & his Wray Men Ψ Run Chicken Run The Ruby Suns Ψ Oh Mojave! Peter & the Wolf Ψ City Birds Peter Bjorn & John Ψ Paris 2004 Matt & Kim Ψ Good Ol' Fashion Nightmare Sparklehorse Ψ Dog Door Erkin Koray Ψ Sur Efem Atini The Coasters Ψ Love Potion No. 9 Cut Chemist Ψ Superman et al. Q-Tip Ψ Move Dj Rupture Ψ Homeboys (cut)
Dj Rupture Ψ Homeboys Angela Davis + RZA Ψ Focus on the Family over Ghostdog tracks Cab Calloway Ψ Tarzan of Harlem Estis Purkle Ψ Facts about Tarzan Sparks Ψ Tarzan and Jane Yap Gene Marshall Ψ Shut Up and Quit Talking Magnetic Fields Ψ Yeah! Oh Yeah! Carl Perkins Ψ Honey Don't Corky Jones Ψ Hot Dog Norma Fraser Ψ The First Cut is the Deepest Meic Stevens Ψ Y Crawdyn Ein Eduardo Mateo Ψ Quien